| Wiktionary:Requests for deletion Dec 30th 2011, 13:11 Tiny Tim: keep as meeting CFI | ← Older revision | Revision as of 13:11, 30 December 2011 | | Line 2,922: | Line 2,922: | | | :::Sorry, we don't have Fred Flinstone, and never have done. [[User:Mglovesfun|Mglovesfun]] ([[User talk:Mglovesfun|talk]]) 04:15, 24 December 2011 (UTC) | | :::Sorry, we don't have Fred Flinstone, and never have done. [[User:Mglovesfun|Mglovesfun]] ([[User talk:Mglovesfun|talk]]) 04:15, 24 December 2011 (UTC) | | | ::'''Comment''' - the vote cited above does not apply here, as neither "Tiny" nor "Tim" is the character's family name or patronymic. I suspect this is an example of a fictional name that has come into attributive use in English, but right now I have neither the time nor inclination to bother. --[[User:EncycloPetey|EncycloPetey]] 23:53, 25 December 2011 (UTC) | | ::'''Comment''' - the vote cited above does not apply here, as neither "Tiny" nor "Tim" is the character's family name or patronymic. I suspect this is an example of a fictional name that has come into attributive use in English, but right now I have neither the time nor inclination to bother. --[[User:EncycloPetey|EncycloPetey]] 23:53, 25 December 2011 (UTC) | | | + | : '''Keep''', as the reason given in the nomination for deletion is invalid ("not a word or an idiom"), and the term seems to meet CFI by actually meeting the more stringent attestation criteria for fictional universes. Details follow. | | | + | : The term in question is a name of a specific entity governed by [[Wiktionary:CFI#Names_of_specific_entities]], a section that correctly states that "Names of fictional people and places are subject to the "Fictional universes" section of this page". As the term in question is a name of a fictional character, it is more specifically governed by [[Wiktionary:CFI#Fictional_universes]]; the entry of the term features quotations chosen to meet that regulation. See also [[Talk:Tiny Tim#RFV]], which shows that the entry has passed RFV in April 2011. | | | + | : Furthermore, [[WT:Votes/pl-2010-12/Names of individuals]] does not apply to "Tiny Tim", as pointed out by EncycloPetey. | | | + | : As an aside, we do have [[Fred Flintstone]] (with "t" after "Flin"), sent to RFV on 15 November 2011. For other names of fictional characters, see [[:Category:en:Fictional_characters]]. Some of these include [[Little Red Riding Hood]] and [[Sherlock Holmes]]. --[[User:Dan Polansky|Dan Polansky]] 13:11, 30 December 2011 (UTC) | | | | | | | | == [[vow of silence]] == | | == [[vow of silence]] == | | |
沒有留言:
張貼留言